The Rothenberg Way
When you are injured, the legal process can feel overwhelming. You may be dealing with pain, medical appointments, missed work, financial stress, insurance questions, and uncertainty about what comes next. From your first call to the final resolution, we are with you every step of the way.
At The Rothenberg Law Firm, our job is to help lift that burden from your shoulders.
From the moment you contact us, we take time to understand what happened, explain your options, and begin protecting your rights. If we accept your case, we move quickly to preserve important evidence, investigate the facts, and build a claim designed to show how the injury happened and how it has affected your life.
For more than 55 years, our firm has represented clients in serious personal injury cases. We prepare cases with care because we understand what is at stake for you and your family.
Our process is built around one core principle: injured people deserve a law firm that is prepared to act quickly, invest deeply, and stand with them through the entire legal process.
That means we:
- Listen carefully from the first call
- Move quickly to protect evidence
- Master the facts, law, and medical issues
- Work with qualified professionals and experts when needed
- Prepare clients for each stage of the case
- Build cases for settlement and trial
- Pursue full and fair compensation under the law
When you hire The Rothenberg Law Firm, you are not just hiring a lawyer. You are hiring a team committed to helping you understand the process, protect your rights, and move forward after a serious injury.
Step 1: Your Free Initial Consultation
Every prospective client is entitled to a free initial consultation with someone from our firm.
During this consultation, we listen to your story, gather important facts, and make an initial assessment of your potential case. You do not need to know all the legal details before you call. Our role is to ask the right questions and help you understand what information may matter.
We may ask about:
- How the accident happened
- Where and when the injury occurred
- The injuries you suffered
- The medical treatment you have received
- Whether there were witnesses, photos, videos, reports, or other evidence
- Whether an insurance company has contacted you
- How the injury has affected your work, family, and daily life
After reviewing the available information, we will let you know whether we believe we can help. In some situations, we may recommend another attorney if there is a professional conflict of interest or if the matter is outside the types of cases we customarily handle.
Our goal is to give you practical guidance from the beginning, with no charge and no obligation.
Step 2: You Do Not Pay Attorneys’ Fees Unless We Recover Compensation for You
Personal injury clients should not have to worry about hourly legal bills while they are already dealing with the consequences of an accident.
That is why The Rothenberg Law Firm handles personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis.
This means you do not pay attorneys’ fees unless there is a recovery through settlement or verdict. Our fee is a percentage of the total recovery, consistent with applicable law and regulations.
In simple terms: you do not pay attorneys’ fees unless we recover compensation for you.
Case costs and expert fees are separate from attorneys’ fees. These may include costs related to filing a lawsuit, serving defendants, obtaining medical records, hiring investigators, consulting experts, preparing evidence, and presenting the case. These costs are customarily addressed at the conclusion of the case. Expert fees are also paid only at the conclusion of your case.
We explain fee arrangements clearly so you understand how the process works before moving forward.
Step 3: We Act Quickly to Protect Your Case
Time matters after an accident.
Accident scenes can change. Witness memories can fade. Video footage can be erased. Vehicles, equipment, products, flooring, sidewalks, stairs, and other physical evidence can be repaired, moved, discarded, or destroyed.
That is why we take prompt action when we accept a case.
Depending on the facts, we may:
- Contact you quickly after your referral or inquiry
- Schedule an interview as soon as possible
- Investigate the accident scene
- Identify and speak with witnesses
- Gather photos, videos, reports, and records
- Preserve key evidence
- Send letters requesting that evidence be maintained
- Consult with appropriate professionals or experts
- Begin evaluating how the accident happened and who may be responsible
We do not believe in letting cases sit. We do not wait for the insurance company to decide what your case is worth. We begin building the case from the start so we can better protect your rights and prepare for the road ahead.
Step 4: We Understand the Facts, the Law, and the Medicine
A strong personal injury case requires more than telling an insurance company that someone was hurt.
It requires showing what happened, who may be responsible, what injuries were caused, and how those injuries changed the client’s life. That requires careful work in three key areas: the facts, the law, and the medical evidence.
The Facts
We investigate how the accident occurred, what evidence exists, who may be responsible, and what witnesses or records can help support the case.
In a vehicle accident case, that may include police reports, crash scene photos, vehicle damage, black box data, surveillance footage, cell phone records, driver history, and witness statements.
In a premises liability case, it may include incident reports, maintenance records, inspection logs, photos of the hazard, surveillance footage, and information about who owned or controlled the property.
Every case is different, so we focus on the specific evidence needed to tell the full story.
The Law
We analyze the law that applies to liability, evidence, damages, and the court where the case may be brought. Different states, courts, and case types may involve different rules.
Our firm represents injured clients across New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. We understand that local law, filing deadlines, insurance rules, and court procedures can affect the strategy of a case. We explain these issues in plain English so you understand the process and your options.
The Medicine
Injury cases often depend on medical proof. It is not enough to say that you are in pain. A strong case should clearly connect the accident to the injuries and explain how those injuries affect your daily life, work, mobility, independence, and future needs.
We review medical records, diagnostic testing, treatment history, physician opinions, and long-term care issues. When needed, we may work with medical professionals, life-care planners, or other experts to better understand the full impact of the injury.
This is especially important in cases involving serious injuries such as traumatic brain injuries, orthopedic injuries, spinal injuries, burns, amputations, complex fractures, and other life-changing trauma.
Step 5: We Invest in the Resources Needed to Build the Case
Insurance companies, corporations, trucking companies, property owners, hospitals, product manufacturers, and other defendants may have significant resources. Injured clients deserve a law firm prepared to meet them with experience, preparation, and the tools needed to present the case clearly.
The Rothenberg Law Firm has spent decades handling personal injury cases. That experience allows us to invest in the people, professionals, and technology needed to prepare serious claims.
Depending on the case, we may work with:
- Medical experts
- Accident reconstruction experts
- Engineers and safety professionals
- Investigators, including experienced former law enforcement professionals
- Medical illustrators
- Trial technology consultants
- Diagnostic and motion analysis providers
- E-discovery and research tools
- Financial, vocational, or life-care planning professionals
These resources help us understand the case fully, present evidence clearly, and prepare for negotiation, mediation, litigation, or trial when necessary.
Our goal is not to move your case as quickly as possible for the convenience of the insurance company. Our goal is to prepare your case carefully and pursue a resolution that reflects the full impact of your injuries.
Step 6: We Prepare Every Case as If It May Go to Trial
Many personal injury cases resolve through settlement, but strong settlements often come from serious preparation.
Insurance companies know which law firms are ready to litigate and which ones are looking for a quick resolution. We believe preparation matters from the beginning.
When appropriate, we develop detailed case presentations that explain:
- How the accident happened
- Why the defendant may be responsible
- What injuries were suffered
- What medical treatment was required
- What future care may be needed
- How the injury affected the client and the client’s family
- What damages may be recoverable under the law
If trial becomes necessary, we may use medical illustrations, accident animations, demonstrative exhibits, trial presentation software, expert testimony, medical records, photographs, videos, and other tools to help a judge or jury understand the full impact of the case.
Being trial-ready does not mean every case will go to trial. It means we prepare carefully so we are ready for whatever path the case requires.
Step 7: We Prepare You for Each Important Stage
Our clients should never feel like they are walking into the unknown.
We take time to prepare you for each major stage of the legal process, including:
- Interviews
- Statements
- Medical evaluations
- Depositions
- Settlement negotiations
- Mediations
- Hearings
- Trial
For example, before a deposition, we may spend significant time helping you understand the types of questions you may be asked, how the process works, and what to expect. A deposition can feel intimidating if you have never been through one before. We help you feel informed, prepared, and supported.
We also keep communication clear throughout the case. You deserve to understand what is happening, why it matters, and what decisions may need to be made.
Step 8: We Pursue a Resolution That Reflects the Full Impact of Your Injuries
Every case is different.
Some cases can be resolved through negotiation. Others require mediation. Some must be litigated and taken to trial. At every stage, our focus is on pursuing a resolution that reflects the evidence, the law, the injuries, the damages, and the effect the accident has had on your life.
We evaluate issues such as:
- The strength of the liability evidence
- The seriousness of your injuries
- Your medical treatment and future care needs
- Your lost income and reduced earning ability
- Your pain, limitations, and loss of enjoyment of life
- The available insurance coverage or assets
- The risks and benefits of settlement or trial
We also make sure you understand your options. Settlement decisions are important. Our job is to give you clear guidance so you can make informed choices about the path forward.
For Referring Attorneys and Professionals
We welcome referrals from attorneys, professional service providers, and others who want trusted personal injury advocates for their clients, friends, or family members.
When you refer someone to The Rothenberg Law Firm, you can expect us to respond promptly, treat the person with respect, and begin offering practical guidance from the start.
Referral sources and co-counsel can rely on our:
- Personal injury experience
- Mission and values
- Case preparation methods
- Litigation resources
- Trial-ready approach
- Professional reputation
- Commitment to client service
Whether you are referring a client or looking to associate with a firm that can add resources and value to a serious injury case, we are ready to help. We will work with you to help ensure the client is well represented and to reach a fair arrangement regarding fees where appropriate and permitted by applicable rules.
Frequently Asked Questions About Our Case Process
How much does it cost to speak with The Rothenberg Law Firm?
Your initial consultation is free. There is no charge and no obligation to speak with someone from our firm about your potential case.
Do I have to pay attorneys’ fees upfront?
No. We handle personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis. That means you do not pay attorneys’ fees unless there is a recovery through settlement or verdict.
What happens after I contact the firm?
We will gather information about what happened, review the available facts, and make an initial assessment of your potential case. If we accept the case, we begin investigating, preserving evidence, reviewing medical issues, and building the claim.
Will my case go to trial?
Not every case goes to trial. Many cases resolve through settlement or mediation. However, we prepare cases carefully so that we are ready to go to trial when necessary.
How long will my personal injury case take?
Every case is different. The timeline may depend on the severity of your injuries, the amount of medical treatment needed, the complexity of the evidence, whether liability is disputed, and whether the case resolves through settlement or requires litigation. Our team keeps clients informed as the case moves forward.
Can attorneys refer cases to your firm?
Yes. We welcome referrals from attorneys and other professionals. We are also available to serve as co-counsel in serious personal injury cases where our experience, resources, and trial preparation may help support the client’s case.
What makes The Rothenberg Law Firm’s process different?
Our process is built around prompt action, careful preparation, client communication, and trial readiness. We work to understand the facts, law, medicine, and full impact of the injury so we can pursue the compensation available under the law.